Mode of trial

Joshua Rozenberg QC's comprehensive discussion on online courts, the challenges it faces, and its progress in both the UK and Canada.

Some criminal cases may be heard only in magistrates' courts; some may be tried only by a jury in the Crown Court; and some may be tried either way. Defendants charged with "either-way" offences are now asked, before the court decides where the case should be tried, whether or not they intend to plead guilty. This is known as "plea-before-venue".

However, requiring defendants to attend court to deal with this process may not be the best use of everyone's time. So the Prisons and Courts Billhttp://services.parliament.uk/bills/2016-17/prisonsandcourts.html proposed new procedures under which a defendant might engage with the plea-before-venue procedure in writing, provided the consequences had been explained to the defendant. Though the bill did not say this, it was intended that this written interaction should take place online, using the Common Platform case management system.

The written information procedure, as it was to be called, would allow a person charged with an offence "to choose to give an indication of whether he or she intends to plead guilty or not guilty" but "may not allow a person charged with an offence to choose to give a plea of guilty or not guilty". Under this procedure, the defendant's plea was to be given in court rather than online. That's in contrast to the automatic online conviction procedure already mentioned, which was to be used only for relatively minor cases. The written information procedure may be used in the early stages of even the most serious cases.

The bill also allowed for magistrates' courts to deal with the mode of trial in the defendant's absence and for cases to be transferred between courts without a hearing.

As drafted, the legislation was very difficult to follow. But the aim was simple enough: to save time and money by dealing with preliminary matters online.

These provisions also lapsed when the bill was abandoned in April 2017.

comments

add a comment

    more

    sign in to your account

    Some features of this website require a user account. If you have one, sign in here; if not, create an account or retrieve your password by clicking on the tabs above.

    create an account

    To create an account, simply enter your email address here and we'll send you a link to complete your details. The link, and the email address you give us, will be destroyed if you don't complete your registration within 24 hours.

    forgotten your password?

    You can regain access to your account by entering your email address below; we'll send you a link that you'll need to use within 24 hours.